How to Read a Compost Lab Report (A Real Penn State Test)

“Lab tested” is easy to print on a bag. A real lab report is harder to read, so most people never look at one. That’s a shame, because a compost analysis answers the questions that actually matter for a lawn: is it finished, is it clean, will it burn new seed, and how much does it really feed?
Here’s a real one, line by line: the Penn State Agricultural Analytical Services Laboratory’s report on a January 2026 batch of Organic Lawn Builder, the dairy-fiber compost made by MYCOguard in Kennett Square that we deliver and spread. We’ll explain what each number means using Penn State’s own interpretation guide, including the numbers that aren’t flattering.

First: “as is” vs. “dry weight”
Every result has two columns. As is is the compost as it arrives, water included. Dry weight takes the water out so batches and products can be compared fairly. This batch was 68% solids, 32% moisture, so every nutrient reads about a third lower “as is” than “dry.”
When you compare composts, compare dry weight to dry weight.
The full report, translated
| Line | As is | Dry weight | What it tells you |
|---|---|---|---|
| pH | 8.7 | Alkaline, typical of manure-based compost | |
| Soluble salts (1:10 w:w) | 2.81 mmhos/cm | Salt level; matters most for seedlings | |
| Solids / moisture | 68% / 32% | Dry enough to spread cleanly | |
| Organic matter | 57.5% | 84.6% | The soil-building part |
| Total nitrogen | 1.4% | 2.0% | All the nitrogen, every form |
| Organic nitrogen | 1.3% | 2.0% | Slow-release nitrogen |
| Ammonium nitrogen | 445 mg/kg | 655 mg/kg | The fast, ready-to-use nitrogen |
| Carbon | 31.0% | 45.6% | Fuel for soil life |
| C:N ratio | 22.6 | Whether it releases or ties up nitrogen | |
| Phosphorus (as P2O5) | 0.33% | 0.49% | Divide by 2.29 for elemental P |
| Potassium (as K2O) | 0.72% | 1.06% | Divide by 1.20 for elemental K |
| Calcium | 1.29% | 1.90% | |
| Magnesium | 0.34% | 0.50% | |
| Particle size under 9.5 mm | 100% | Fine enough to top-dress | |
| Plastic, metal, glass | 0.00% | No trash in it | |
| Fecal coliform | under 1.8 MPN/g | under 3 MPN/g | Pathogen indicator |
Now the lines that deserve a closer look.
Organic matter: 84.6%
This is the headline. Penn State’s guide says finished compost typically runs 30 to 70% organic matter on a dry basis, and that 50 to 60% is desirable for most uses. At 84.6%, this batch is well above both.
For a lawn, organic matter is the whole point. It’s what rebuilds the spongy top layer, the O horizon, that holds water and nutrients and improves soil tilth. Nutrients you can buy in any bag; organic matter is what most lawns are actually short on.
Nitrogen: mostly slow-release
Total nitrogen is 2.0% dry. Of that, nearly all is organic nitrogen (2.0% dry), and only a small slice is ammonium (655 mg/kg, about 0.07%), the form plants use immediately.
That’s the slow-release story in numbers. Penn State’s guide describes organic nitrogen in compost as only slowly available, roughly 10 to 20% a year, depending on the C:N ratio, soil moisture and temperature. So a compost top-dressing keeps feeding over several seasons instead of greening the lawn for three weeks and washing away.
If you want a faster green-up on top of that, that’s what Organic Lawn Builder Plus is for: organic blood meal blended in on site, which adds nitrogen and iron.
C:N ratio: 22.6
The carbon-to-nitrogen ratio predicts what the compost does to nitrogen in your soil. Penn State’s rule of thumb:
- Below 20: likely to release (mineralize) nitrogen to plants
- Above 30: likely to tie up (immobilize) soil nitrogen while microbes break the carbon down
- 20 to 30: the middle
At 22.6, this compost sits in the middle: it isn’t a quick nitrogen source, and it isn’t high enough to rob the grass. That fits what it’s designed to be, a fiber-rich soil builder rather than a fertilizer. At a thin 1/8 to 1/4 inch top-dressing, the effect on the lawn’s nitrogen either way is small.
pH: 8.7
This is alkaline, and it’s typical of manure-based composts. Penn State’s guide puts most finished composts between 5.0 and 8.5, so 8.7 is just above that range.
Before you worry: the same guide notes that compost pH measures active acidity only and can’t be used to predict the compost’s effect on soil pH. A thin top-dressing doesn’t move a lawn’s pH much, and many Pennsylvania lawns lean acidic anyway. If you’re unsure, a soil test tells you, and we’d always rather you test than guess.
Soluble salts: 2.81 mmhos/cm
Salts matter most for germinating seed. Penn State’s guide gives a typical compost range of 1 to 10 mmhos/cm, but measured in a 1:5 compost-to-water slurry. This report was run at 1:10, which dilutes the sample twice as much, so the two numbers aren’t directly comparable.
The more useful answer is the plant test: in seedling germination studies with Penn State, this compost had a 100% success rate. Seed sown into it came up.
Phosphorus and potassium: read the footnote
Like fertilizer bags, labs report these as oxides. The report’s own footnote gives the conversion:
- P2O5 0.49% ÷ 2.29 = about 0.21% elemental phosphorus (dry)
- K2O 1.06% ÷ 1.20 = about 0.88% elemental potassium (dry)
Penn State notes that how much of compost’s phosphorus and potassium plants can use hasn’t been established, and that they can build up with repeated heavy applications. That’s another reason a soil test and thin, spaced-out applications are the right approach. Pennsylvania’s fertilizer law also limits phosphorus on lawns; we explain it in Pennsylvania’s lawn fertilizer law, explained.
The cleanliness lines
- Plastic, metal and glass: 0.00%. Composts made from municipal or mixed waste can carry trash. This one carries none.
- Particle size: 100% under 9.5 mm (about 3/8 inch). Fine enough to drop between grass blades.
- Fecal coliform: under 3 MPN per gram, dry. This is the lab’s indicator for pathogens. For comparison, the federal Class A standard for biosolids is fewer than 1,000 MPN per gram. The material is pasteurized as part of MYCOguard’s process, which is also why it’s weed-free.
What we take from it
A good lawn compost report should show high organic matter, mostly organic (slow) nitrogen, a C:N ratio that won’t rob the soil, no trash, a clean pathogen result and a passing seedling test. This one does. The pH runs high, which is worth knowing, and worth a soil test if your lawn is already alkaline.
If you’re comparing composts, ask any supplier for this report. If they can’t produce one, that tells you something too.
Get it delivered
We deliver Organic Lawn Builder within 30 miles of Kennett Square, PA, including Chester County, the Main Line and northern Delaware: delivered, or delivered and spread. Call or text 844-445-2969. The story behind it, from the scientist who makes it, is worth a read too.
Interpretation ranges in this article come from the Penn State Agricultural Analytical Services Laboratory’s compost report guide.
Frequently asked
What is a good C:N ratio for compost?
Penn State's lab explains it as a range: a compost with a C:N ratio below 20 is likely to release nitrogen to plants, and one above 30 is likely to tie up soil nitrogen. Between 20 and 30 is the middle ground. Thin top-dressing layers make the effect small either way.
Why does a compost report list phosphorus as P2O5?
Labs report phosphorus and potassium as oxides (P2O5 and K2O), the same way fertilizer bags do. To convert to elemental phosphorus divide P2O5 by 2.29; for elemental potassium divide K2O by 1.20.
What's the difference between 'as is' and 'dry weight' on a compost report?
'As is' is the compost as delivered, water included. 'Dry weight' removes the water so batches can be compared fairly. A compost that is 32% moisture will show every nutrient about a third lower 'as is' than on a dry basis.
Does a high compost pH raise my lawn's pH?
Penn State's lab notes that compost pH measures active acidity only and can't be used to predict the compost's effect on soil pH. At a thin top-dressing rate the effect on soil is small; a soil test is the way to know what your lawn needs.
Keep reading
Tips & MaintenanceMushroom Country Compost Meets Robot Mowers in Kennett SquareHow a robot-mowing experiment and a Kennett Square compost lab became Organic Lawn Builder: certified-organic feeding for Chester County lawns, less runoff.

Explore the system
The mowers and pages behind this topic — see them sized to your yard.